Animal behaviour
How a Honeybee Swarm Chooses Its Next Home
A cluster of thousands of bees hanging from a branch has only a few days to pick a new nest site. The way it decides looks a lot like an election.
By Mira Okonkwo · 12 min read
Late in spring, a strong honeybee colony does something that looks reckless. The old queen and roughly two thirds of the workers leave the hive they built, fly a short distance, and settle as a hanging cluster on a tree branch. The daughters left behind keep the old comb, the stored honey and a new queen who will soon emerge. The swarm keeps almost nothing. It carries honey in its members' stomachs, which buys it a few days, and it has a problem to solve before that runs out: it needs a new home, and it needs to agree on one.
A swarm cannot afford to choose badly. A cavity that is too small will not hold enough comb to store honey for winter. An entrance that is too large lets in cold air and robbers. A site on the ground floods. Bees that pick the wrong place may not survive the next cold season, so the decision carries the whole colony's future. Biologists who have studied the process for decades describe it as one of the clearest examples of group decision-making in nature.
The scouts go out
Only a small fraction of the swarm takes part in the search. A few hundred older foragers become scouts. They leave the cluster and spread out over the surrounding landscape, inspecting knotholes, hollow trunks, gaps in walls and the occasional empty nest box. A scout that finds a promising cavity does not judge it at a glance. She walks inside, sometimes for many minutes, pacing the interior in a way that seems to let her estimate its volume. She checks the size of the entrance, how high it sits above the ground, and whether the inside is dry.
Researchers learned what the bees prefer by offering them choices. In experiments that set out rows of boxes that differed in only one feature, swarms showed consistent tastes. They favoured a cavity of around forty litres over smaller or much larger ones. They liked an entrance that was small, near the bottom of the cavity, and several metres off the ground. A box that already smelled of old comb was more attractive than a clean one. None of these preferences is absolute, but together they describe a home that is easy to defend and easy to keep warm.
When a scout returns to the cluster, she reports what she found by dancing on the surface of the swarm. This is the same waggle dance that foragers use to point their sisters toward flowers. The angle of the waggle run relative to vertical encodes the direction of the site relative to the sun, and the length of the run encodes its distance. A scout that found an excellent cavity dances many circuits with enthusiasm. A scout that found a mediocre one dances only a few circuits, or none at all.
Debate without a debate
At first the dances point in many directions at once. Different scouts have found different sites, and each advertises her own. To an observer it looks like a crowded room where everyone is talking. Over the next hours, though, something changes. Bees that have not yet chosen a site watch the dances, follow one of them out to the advertised location, and inspect it for themselves. If they like it, they return and dance for it too.
The key detail is that a scout's enthusiasm fades. Each time she returns from her site, she dances fewer circuits than the time before, and eventually she stops dancing altogether. She does not switch to a rival site out of persuasion. She simply goes quiet. Because better sites earn longer dances, they recruit new supporters faster than poorer sites lose old ones. Support for weak sites dries up on its own, while support for the strongest site keeps growing.
Some scouts do more than promote their own choice. When a bee dancing for one site meets a bee dancing for another, she may butt her head against the rival dancer and make a short vibrating sound. This stop signal makes the receiving dancer more likely to cut her dance short. Models of the process suggest that this cross-inhibition helps a swarm avoid a deadlock between two equally good sites, which could otherwise split the colony in two.
Counting heads at the door
A swarm does not wait for every dancer to agree. The decision is reached at the candidate sites themselves. Scouts that visit a cavity can sense how many other scouts are present there. When the number at one site passes a threshold, often estimated at somewhere between twenty and thirty bees at the same time, the scouts there behave differently. Instead of flying back to dance, they return to the cluster and start preparing everyone else for departure.
This quorum rule trades accuracy against speed. A higher threshold would make mistakes rarer but would leave the swarm hanging exposed on its branch for longer. A lower threshold would let the colony move sooner but would sometimes commit to a site that only a lucky handful of scouts had discovered early. The number the bees use appears to sit in a range where they rarely choose badly and rarely wait too long.
Once the quorum is sensed, the scouts begin piping, a high-pitched sound made by pressing the body against other bees and vibrating the flight muscles. Piping tells the thousands of resting bees to warm up. Bees in a hanging cluster let their outer layers cool to save energy, and they cannot fly until their flight muscles reach about thirty-five degrees Celsius. Over the following hour the whole swarm shivers itself up to flying temperature.
The flight to the new nest
Lift-off looks chaotic. The cluster dissolves into a cloud several metres wide that drifts across the landscape. Only a small minority of the bees in that cloud has ever seen the destination. The rest are guided by a few hundred informed scouts that streak through the cloud at high speed in the direction of the new home, then loop back slowly along its edges and streak through again. The uninformed bees appear to follow these fast-moving guides.
Arrival is quick. Scouts that reach the site first gather at the entrance and fan their wings, releasing an odour from a gland on the abdomen that helps the others find the opening. Within minutes the cloud funnels inside. Wax glands start working almost immediately, and within a day the colony has begun building fresh comb from the ceiling of its new cavity.
What engineers borrowed
The swarm's method has drawn attention well beyond biology. It solves a problem that people also face: choosing one option from many when no single member has seen all the options, and when information arrives piece by piece. The bees succeed without a leader. The queen plays no role in the choice. No bee compares all the sites, and no bee needs to.
Several features make the process work. Scouts evaluate sites independently before they are swayed by others, which keeps early errors from spreading. Support for each option grows in proportion to its quality, so good options win more often. Enthusiasm decays over time, so the group does not get locked into a position simply because it was popular first. And the final commitment depends on a quorum rather than unanimity, which keeps the process fast.
Researchers have pointed out that these features resemble principles for good committee work: let people form their own opinions before discussion, encourage open debate, and use a clear rule to end it. Computer scientists have built search and routing algorithms that copy the scouts' dances, and roboticists have used similar rules to let groups of simple robots agree on a location without central control.
For the bees, the payoff is concrete. A swarm that chooses well can build comb, raise a new generation of workers, and store enough honey before autumn to survive the winter. A swarm that chooses poorly often dies. Every spring, on branches and fence posts, thousands of colonies run the same quiet election, and most of them pick the best home available.
If you find a swarm hanging in your garden, the best thing to do is usually nothing. A clustered swarm is rarely aggressive, because it has no comb or brood to defend. Within a day or two, sometimes within hours, it will finish its decision and leave. A local beekeeping association can often collect it if it has settled somewhere inconvenient.